Authorial Intent – A Pox On It If The Author Is A Giant Douche

I was reading up on the Machete Order of viewing the Star Wars canon films and it jogged my memory on a discussion related to the issue and one of those many, MANY depictions of fiction that took inspiration from it in Western popular culture, Avatar: The Last Airbender.

I was talking to someone who watched Sozin’s Comet for the first time and we were discussing about the show’s similarity with SW. (including the split final battle) He mentioned that a ROTJ that combined Conan the Barbarian cinematography with Aang’s communion with his self-spirits would make for a better Luke-centric show. Basically, in place of the spirits we’ll have the various force ghosts, perhaps arguing for and against Vader and what he originally was. Flashback prequel footage (COMPETENTLY DONE) could be used to highlight his humanity or lack of. I mean, if Ahnuld could make a film out of CtB it could easily be done with a less than stellar Mark Hamill.

There’s also immense irony and a splendid callout factor to have Hamill come back essentially as the anime version of the Emperor. Vader had become a peer of the protagonist in the form of Zuko, so there’s some interesting variations of the theme done here. Someone should put Hamill on a commentary track for those last few episodes.

Rurouni Kenshin – Cinema-ban: Quick Impressions

Well, the first chapter of the “reboot” of Kenshin to coincide with the live action movie has been scanlated.

I have only one thing to say after reading it: what a clusterfuck.

In just 40 odd pages, characters introduced: Kenshin, Kaoru, Yahiko, Saito, Jin-e, Sanosuke, Kanryuu Takeda (Megumi’s drug boss) and some other miscellaneous guys I don’t remember the names of. What the hell? Never mind Kaoru’s predicament is now pretty damn retarded.

It could possibly be that Watsuki only gets a limited number of chapters to tell his tale, but in that case the series should have just focused on the parts that are relevant to the live action movie (i.e. the fights), rather than rebooting the story in such a sloppy fashion.

On the plus side, the art is more polished. Won’t be enough reason to stick around if the story does not improve rapidly though.

From ANN:

The May issue of Shueisha’s Jump Square magazine revealed on Wednesday that Nobuhiro Watsuki’s new Kenshin manga series, Rurouni Kenshin -Cinema-ban- (Rurouni Kenshin: Cinema Version), will focus on battles fought with characters from the upcoming live-action film. The issue has a feature promoting the “reboot” of the Rurouni Kenshin series, although the magazine is not necessarily using the term “reboot” with the English denotation in mind. The new manga series will begin in the next issue of Jump Square on May 2.

Read it on Batoto

Trailer of the live action movie for anybody who’s not seen it:

『RUROUNI KENSHIN』 Trailer1 (English)

Must say, it looks bad. This is a pretty damn good argument for the existence of anime and animation in general. The Tsuiokuhen (追憶編, Trust and Betrayal) with its serious moods, somewhat realistic fights and not to mention that outstanding story will make for an awesome live action adaptation done properly, but there is just no way the “ORO?”s and ridiculous techniques (what the fuck was that running with the body at an acute angle to the ground?) will translate well.